At Inukshuk Capital Management, our focus is on building lasting relationships rooted in trust and collaboration. By focusing on active risk management and long-term value creation, we help families and institutions achieve financial sustainability.
Stay up-to-date on the latest developments by following us on LinkedIn here.
In this issue:
- Global Equity Market Performance
- Indexes
- The Big 10
- Equal Weight
- Recent Developments
- Wrapping Up
Global Equity Market Performance
MSCI Emerging Markets led the pack for the second month in a row, rising 2.0%. The other three index ETFs we track were down. The S&P 500 fell 0.5%, MSCI EAFE 0.7% and the S&P/TSX 60 2.4%.
Last month we made the case that September has historically been the worst month, but there isn’t a practical way to manage that risk. September was negative again this year, but the decline was modest compared with the historical average September return of about -1.1%.
For the quarter, the S&P 500 was the winner, up 1.8%. The S&P/TSX 60, despite a poor September, closed 1.6% higher. MSCI EAFE gained 0.4% while MSCI Emerging Markets was the sole loser, down 1.8%.
As of this writing—the second full week of October—our systems are indicating positive momentum in all four equity markets.
If you would like to stay current on our measures of trend and momentum in the markets we follow, please click here.
This letter takes a look at the relative performance of the S&P 500 index versus the equal-weighted S&P 500.
Indexes
Our July letter underlined the importance of knowing what you own. The impact of a few companies on index ETF performance can be remarkable. The iShares MSCI country index ETF for South Korea (EWY) was dominated by two companies at that time. SK Hynix and Samsung made up almost 50% of the index due to their performance and the index design.
Many equity indexes, and therefore the ETFs that track them, are weighted by market capitalization. That means the largest, best-performing companies will be the biggest holdings. One of the largest and most heavily traded equity ETFs in the world is the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY), is market-cap weighted.
Weighting an index by market capitalization could be described as a strategy. The best performers become increasingly important, while the worst fade away. In trading lingo, that resembles letting your winners ride and cutting your losers. The index does that for you. You still own the underlying companies, but the smallest holdings barely register. For example, News Corporation is the smallest position, at 0.05%.
As an aside, the granddaddy of indexes, the Dow Jones Industrial Average, is constructed based on price. The higher-priced stocks in the index have the largest weight. Goldman Sachs (GS) has the largest weighting at 10%, because its price is $876. Nike (NKE) has a 0.4% weighting because its price is $35. That isn’t really a strategy—more an artifact of its original design.
So why are we writing about this now?
The Big 10
As stocks continue to rally during bull markets, more people start to pay attention and ask questions. One of the questions being discussed: Are a few large tech companies that dominate the S&P 500 a risk to the overall market?
As of October 12, six of the 10 largest companies in the S&P 500 were formally classified in the Information Technology sector. Several of the others—including Alphabet (GOOGL), Meta (META) and Amazon (AMZN)—are also highly technology-driven businesses.
That’s not quite the South Korea level of concentration, but it looks significant.
Let’s put it into context. In January, RBC Wealth Management published a note with the below chart showing the concentration of the 10 largest companies in the S&P 500 every five years going back to 1990.
At the end of 2025 and as of last week, the top 10 represent more than 40% of the index. During the dot-com boom the weighting was 23.2%. And there were worries then.
A related trend is the kind of companies representing the top 10. In April of last year, Visual Capitalist, a market data analysis site, published a table showing the actual companies and weights.
Over time, technology has become dominant. Even comparing the names today to 2024 shows that trend. There were six non-tech firms then, but now the bank (JPM) and the pharma company (LLY) have been replaced by two chipmakers, Micron Technology (MU) and Advanced Micro Devices (AMD). Before the dot-com boom there was one tech company, IBM. In 2000 there were three. Now there are six.
Let’s look at a strategy designed to reduce concentration risk.
Equal Weight
The S&P 500 Equal Weight Index assigns the same weight to each company in the index. The Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) tracks this index. Its inception date is April 24, 2003. The date is interesting—that was seven months after the S&P 500 closed at its low following a 50% decline from the dot-com top. Big moves can motivate Wall Street to create new products.
This chart shows the price performance of RSP and SPY since that date.
If you squint, that looks fairly close.
Let’s compare the relative performance. This next chart shows the ratio of RSP to SPY. When the blue line is going up, RSP is outperforming.
In the first four years of trading, RSP outperformed SPY by just over 23%. Things got a little wobbly during the financial crisis but then its outperformance continued and maxed out in 2015, roughly 12 years after its inception. The 2020 shock had a similar outcome. Its outperformance continued after the March pandemic panic low in 2020 and persisted until a few months after the release of ChatGPT in November 2022. Since then it has underperformed by 27.2%.
That amounts to a little more than a complete round trip since 2003.
RSP’s relative performance does tell us something about market breadth, but this history does not suggest an obvious signal for when concentration risk is about to matter.
Attempting to switch between the two to manage concentration risk might bring more trouble than the effort is worth. If the risks of the AI boom and the consequent concentration of technology in the S&P 500 caused an investor to go the equal-weight route, they would have ridden a relative downtrend for the past three and a half years.
Recent Developments
On October 1, the 10-year Treasury yield traded above 5.34%. According to Reuters, its highest level since 2002. The 10-year yield is an important price for many financial products, so that story continues to be in the news along with US mortgage rates, which are tied to the longer end of the yield curve.
Canadian government bonds are on the same trend. In mid-August, the Canadian 10-year yield was roughly 3.65%. On October 1, it traded as high as 4.04%, its highest level since late 2023.
On October 9, Statistics Canada released the September Labour Force Survey. It showed a loss of 68,000 jobs following a decline of 42,000 in August.
As of October 14, the S&P/TSX 60 is up 1.7% month-to-date and the S&P 500 is up 0.9%.
Wrapping Up
As mentioned, index construction resembles a trading strategy. In the S&P 500’s case, it holds the winners and the losers become less relevant. With an equal-weight index ETF, at each quarterly rebalance, every stock is reset to roughly the same weight, which gives the portfolio greater exposure to smaller S&P 500 companies and systematically trims relative winners while adding to relative losers.
Equal weighting can outperform, but it is not automatically defensive. It can lag badly during strong bull markets and still participate meaningfully in market drawdowns. Reducing concentration does not necessarily mean reducing risk
Trends in large markets tend to persist. The trend in the equal-weight strategy versus a market-cap strategy has been generally down since ChatGPT spurred the AI boom. Maybe that continues.
Concentration concerns are valid. But simply because these companies are considered tech companies doesn’t necessarily mean the risks to their businesses are equal. We wrote about that in the February letter regarding the software slump. January was a rough month for software companies—Microsoft (MSFT) was down 11.0%. Nvidia (NVDA), the largest component of the S&P 500, was up 2.4%. Both are technology companies that have benefited from the AI boom that has helped keep them in the top 10.
If we think of these weighting methodologies as competing strategies, we should treat them the same way we treat any strategy: test them thoroughly before deploying them. For now, we do not see compelling evidence that simply replacing market-cap exposure with equal weight provides a systematic way to improve risk-adjusted returns.
Enjoy the, so far, balmy October.
Have a question? Contact us here
Challenging the status quo of the Canadian investment industry.
















